Wednesday 10 May 2006

Travelling outside karma: U2's Grace

Tonight while I was washing the dishes I listened to U2’s sublime song, “Grace” (2000). I need to listen to this song every now and then, just to be reminded that I still know nothing at all about grace. Many preachers, perhaps even many theologians, do not understand the grace of God half as well as this song does.

The song depicts grace as a beautiful woman who creates music wherever she goes, a woman who “travels outside of karma,” while carrying a single pearl. The woman’s entire existence is nothing more or less than a single, unconditional Yes to the world, a Yes that heals and forgives without a second thought, a Yes that cancels every debt and covers every shameful thing. Her existence is an embodied contradiction of all “karma,” of getting what you deserve. You never get what you deserve from this woman; from her you deserve only silence, but instead she stops to talk, and when she’s near you, “you can hear the strings.” And so the woman finds and creates beauty wherever she goes.

The song’s personification of grace is superb; but the music is just as important, especially that simple, carefree guitar riff on which the whole song rests. Even before Bono starts to sing, this riff itself already conveys everything the song wants to say about grace. The riff is as smooth as a woman’s hips, as soft and easy as her footsteps on the street. In its seamless, circular perfection, it’s like the “pearl in perfect condition” that the woman carries. From the moment we first hear those notes, we know that we are in another world, travelling “outside of karma.” This effortless riff is itself the contradiction of all karma and all works-righteousness.

Beneath everything else in the song—Bono’s voice, the percussion, the guitars and synths that rise momentarily out of darkness and then fade again—beneath all this, that single, carefree riff still follows its own uninterrupted path. Even when Bono begins for a moment to lapse into a kind of vocal works-righteousness, with his too-strenuous repetition of the final line, the guitar riff continues undisturbed, so that the small vocal flaw is sublated and transformed, caught up and carried on the gentle rhythms of grace.

It’s no accident that the song both begins and ends with this guitar riff. At first, we hear nothing but the riff—and when every other instrument has faded into silence, for a moment we hear again only those same pulsing notes, the notes that continue on their way when all else has ceased. In the end, there is only grace.


Patrik said...

My friend sang that at our wedding.

revdrron said...

What do Bono & Barth have in common?

Sam Charles Norton said...

Possibly my favourite song of all time; one I quote religiously (no pun intended).

David W. Congdon said...

There's a sermon illustration here, no doubt.

U2 Sermons said...

Ben, thanks for the heads-up on this. I have just linked it on the U2 Sermons blog.

Drew said...


David Williamson said...

In the UK release, the closing riff of Grace flowed into the magisterial Ground Beneath Her Feet (lyrics by Salman Rushdie).

All my life, I worshipped her
Her golden voice, her beauty’s beat
How she made us feel
How she made me real
And the ground beneath her feet
And the ground beneath her feet

Anonymous said...

"What do Bono and Barth have in common?"

Lots of possibilities, but here's a couple of less-obvious ones:

-- "A splendid father complex" (Barth's recounting of his psychoanalyst's observations, quoted by Eberhard Busch in his Barth biography).

-- A fascination with the thought that Jesus would have washed Judas' feet, too (Barth in an exegetical excursus in the Church Dogmatics; Bono with towel in hand during ZooTV performances of "Until the End of the World").

Ben Myers said...

"What do Bono and Barth have in common?" One more thing: an aversion to right-wing politics!

byron smith said...

I was disappointed Bono didn't make it onto your 'poets for theologians' list.

we-the-helping-hands said...

very nice... I also blogged... d lyrics n guitar tabs :)
I like ur blog :)

Post a Comment


Contact us

Although we're not always able to reply, please feel free to email the authors of this blog.

Faith and Theology © 2008. Template by Dicas Blogger.